Coaching Staff
Alex Anaya enters his 15th year of coaching high school baseball. He began his coaching career as the head baseball coach at Northland Prep Academy in Flagstaff, Arizona, before relocating with his family to Northern Colorado.
Since moving to Colorado, Coach Anaya has served one season as an assistant coach at Mead High School and six seasons in the same role at Loveland High School. Throughout his time as a varsity assistant, he had the opportunity to coach under the leadership and mentorship of his father-in-law, former professional baseball player Greg Brock. Learning from Brock provided invaluable experience and insight that has prepared Coach Anaya to start and build the baseball program at Timnath.
Coach Anaya firmly believes that athletics play a vital role in teaching life lessons. The Timnath Cubs Baseball Program is built on a foundation of strong work ethic, determination, and perseverance. Baseball is a humbling game, and he emphasizes the importance of showing up each day with a positive attitude and a willingness to put in the work, and those are habits that lead not only to success on the field, but also to the development of strong character.
A core value of the Timnath Cubs Baseball Program is the importance of surrounding student athletes with high-quality assistant coaches. Coach Anaya believes that a strong, unified coaching staff, one that models consistency, accountability, and care for players, plays a critical role in the continued growth and success of the program. The commitment and expertise of all the coaches help create an environment where players are supported, challenged, and developed both on and off the field.
Outside of baseball, Coach Anaya enjoys spending time with his wife, Taylor, and their children Baylee and Austin, embracing the Colorado lifestyle through camping, hiking, snowboarding, hunting, fishing, trail running with his dog Brew, and barbecuing with friends and family.
Coach Furtner is beginning his 18th year of coaching high school baseball and his fourth at Timnath. Prior to coaching to Timnath, Coach Furtner has had stints at Fossil Ridge, Valor Christian, and Legend High School- being apart of one state championship team and two other elite eight teams. Coach Furtner’s specialties include hitting, base running, and outfield instruction. He believes in the importance of building strong relationships with his athletes.
Coach Furtner is a graduate of Colorado State University where he played baseball for three years. A certified strength and conditioning specialist, Coach Furtner moved down to Florida where he was head performance coach at Cooper Sports Performance where he trained athletes, including ones from the Tampa Bay Rays, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and the University of South Florida.
Outside of his role at Timnath, Coach Furtner is a physical education teacher at Kinard Middle School. He lives in Johnstown with his wife, Emily, and their dog, Penelope. In his spare time, he enjoys working out, skiing, and reading.
Coach Rotner has been a head coach in baseball for over 10 years, and is entering his second year of coaching at Timnath High School. In that time Coach Rotner has worked with players at various skill levels, attending high level coaching clinics, and has worked with a number of other coaches as well. Coach Rotner also helped start the Force Program, which has made a large imprint on Northern Colorado.
One of the values or ideals that Coach Rotner believes in is attitude and effort, as well as overcoming adversity, and handling success. By holding this standard Coach Rotner hopes to impart certain skills on and beyond the diamond in helping these young men develop into good people and excellent ball players. Coach Rotner is very happy to be a part of a program which holds to the same standards and beliefs.
Outside of baseball Coach Rotner enjoys spending time with his family, wife Jaime and sons Aiden and Carson, traveling when possible, walking his crazy dog Ozzy, and helping his former students succeed in college or life after high school.
Will Cordan is excited to be back for his fourth year as the team’s Pitching Coach. A local to the Fort Collins area for most of his life, he grew up playing high school ball and loves giving back to the program.
You’ll see him around campus during the day, he serves as the Head Custodian at Timnath Middle-High School, so he’s always nearby to support the students and the facilities. He also has a creative side and holds a BFA in Illustration. Looking forward to another great season with the team.
Anthony Kargoll enters his 2nd year of coaching high school baseball. He began his coaching career at Timnath Middle-High School in 2025, after serving as youth baseball umpire in Highlands Ranch for 5 years.
Since joining the Timnath Cubs in 2025, Coach Kargoll has served as an assistant JV coach during the spring season, and an assistant coach on the 16U/15U Summer Travel team. Coach Kargoll will serve as a head coach for the 15U Timnath Cubs summer team.
Coach Kargoll believes that baseball shows its players the path to becoming the ultimate self-improver. Baseball as a game cannot be perfected, but the pursuit of perfection is still the standard. There is always something a player to improve on, and that desire to strive for perfection, even though it can never be obtained, is one of the biggest lessons that baseball teaches. When father time finally comes calling a player hangs up their spikes, the lessons baseball taught will stick well into every player’s post-baseball life. A baseball player, if taught by the game right, will become someone who strives for perfection for the rest of their life.
Along with baseball, Coach Kargoll completed his student teaching in social studies at Timnath Middle-High School in Spring 2025. Currently, he is a history graduate teaching assistant and master’s student at Colorado State University.
Outside of baseball, Coach Kargoll enjoys spending time with family and friends; reading, and finding time to get outside in our lovely state.
Tyler Stotts begins his first season as a high school baseball coach at Timnath Middle-High School, bringing a strong playing background and several years of coaching experience to the program.
Coach Stotts has spent the past four years coaching youth baseball, where he focused on player development, fundamentals, and building a positive team culture. His coaching philosophy emphasizes effort, accountability, and learning the game the right way.
A former outfielder/pitcher, Coach Stotts played Legion baseball for Cheyenne Post 6 from 2002–2006 before continuing his career at Central Arizona College, where he competed at the collegiate level. His experience as a pitcher provides a strong foundation in game strategy, preparation, and mental toughness.
Coach Stotts holds a Bachelor’s degree in Horticulture from Colorado State University, reflecting his passion for growth, discipline, and long-term development—values he brings to both the classroom and the baseball field.
When Coach Stotts isn’t coaching, he enjoys spending time with his amazing wife and their four children. As a family, they love gardening, shredding on the slopes, camping, and evening walks. Coach Stotts is excited to build strong relationships and a positive culture within the Timnath baseball program.